My teammate had an ACL repair for a torn ACL, why is a different ACL surgery being recommended for me?

Over the years in my practice, this has become a familiar question—many patients come to my clinic wondering about their options for anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) surgery. These patients range from recreational athletes who sustained an ACL tear skiing, to the student athletes with an ACL tear from competing in high-level, pivot-heavy sports. My first response to my patients is that there is no one-size-fits-all approach to ACL surgery. Every case is unique. There are many factors that go into determining the right type of surgical or non-surgical solution for their ACL injury, including:


  • Location and type of tear:
    Most ACL tears occur in the middle or mid-substance of the ACL, and can be partial, meaning part of the ligament is torn, or complete, where the ligaments is torn in half. Less frequently we see an avulsion type ACL injury, where the ACL “peels off” from its attachment to the bone. These injuries are all ACL tears, but the treatments are not all the same.
  • Chronicity of the tear
    We want to know if this a recent ACL injury, or if the ACL injury of the knee occurred months to years ago, as this affects healing patterns.
  • Age & activity level
    The age, activity level, and future expectations of the patient are each critical factors in determining my approach to ACL surgery. Is the patient low demand, meaning their exercise comes from a bike ride on the weekends or yoga classes after work? Or, are they high demand, and a high level college athlete that plays cutting and pivoting sports?  
  • Surgical history
    I am looking to determine what prior knee surgery the patient has had on the injured knee, as well as the other knee and joints.
  • Imaging results
    These results help us see if there is a fracture or break in the bone where the ACL attaches, a tear in the meniscus (shock absorber), or damage to the cartilage (smooth glossy coating over the bones).


  1. Exam results
    This includes the evaluation in the office where we assess areas of pain and other stabilizing ligaments in your knee to see how stable your knee is. We also examine the anatomy of your knee to ensure alignment and mobility.  

These are just some of the factors that go into making the appropriate treatment choice to heal your ACL injury. While your friend, colleague or teammate may have had a different approach and experience with their ACL injury treatment, it doesn’t mean yours will be the same. Have a detailed discussion with your doctor about your options, and come up with a plan that works best for you.

adminMy teammate had an ACL repair for a torn ACL, why is a different ACL surgery being recommended for me?